My Chemical Romance gets a lot of guff. They're one of those bands that became so popular so quickly than anyone with the least bit of elitism in their blood wrote them off on principle. The goth make-up, swoopy emo boy haircuts and fifteen year-old girl fanbase didn't help their case, either.
If you write off bands for their public image, you're probably going to miss the good they have to offer. And this is a band that has some good to offer. First of all, this particular album is a huge leap from the band's sophomore effort, Three Cheers for Sweet Revenge. On The Black Parade, My Chemical Romance demonstrates an expertise in musicianship they never managed to highlight before. Additionally, they utilize music technology—the mix of this album is fantastic, using panning and effects in a way that accentuates the songs rather than distracting from them.
So what is it about The Black Parade that's so progressive? First of all, this is a coherent concept album, something rarely seen in the genre—particularly from a band as popular as this one. Second, this is accomplished with a dynamic range of influences, as the album quickly establishes.
The first song, "The End," starts off with an intro heavily laden with acoustic guitar and piano. From there, it bursts into a theatrical layering of guitars, drums and vocals so reminiscent of Pink Floyd's "In The Flesh" that it's a wonder the band didn't sue. These theatrics have a consistent presence in the album; the first single, "Welcome To The Black Parade," sounds more like a Queen song than a punk one.
The theme of this concept album is something that's hard for people to look at, especially young people—who are the target audience. This is an album about mortality. While the album does take a lighthearted approach in a few songs, those that are more serious are definitely worthy of praise. While there are a lot of bands that have written songs about death over the years, many of them did so to explore the romance of it... to glorify it. This album doesn't do that. This is an album that intends to make young people look at the horrors of death and laments of the dying so they can learn to value the opportunities they have in their lives.